28 December, 2006

How I learned to stop worrying and love Doctor Who

Last night we watched The Runaway Bride with a group of friends. No - not that awful Julia Roberts movie, but the brand new Christmas episode of Doctor Who.

I always feel a sense of trepidation and nervous tension when watching a new Doctor Who story for the first time. This doesn't happen with anything else I watch. I’m working my way through the latest episodes of Heroes and Battlestar Galactica at the moment and although they’re both great series, I'm able to relax and enjoy them with no effort.

It's the acute awareness I think that a Doctor Who story's events and revelations need to be absorbed into the series' continuity; what fans sometimes refer to rather ostentatiously as the "canon". Every scene, every line will be picked apart and analysed in great detail in books, magazines and websites ad infinitum. There are books (such as the rather brilliant About Time series) still being published now which take a fresh look at the minutiae of the continuity dating back over 43 years, so you just know that whatever crops up in a brand new episode will be scrutinised for a long time to come.

However there’s a persuasive counter-argument for not doing this, at least on a first time viewing – but rather instead just enjoying the story as a piece of escapist entertainment. Don’t look for the bits that contradict something that happened in an episode that screened thirty years ago. Relax and just enjoy. Sometimes easier said than done.

Many years ago I assisted my good friend Jon Preddle with research for his book Timelink (previously issued by TSV Books and soon to be professionally published by Telos in the UK). Timelink is an awesomely detailed chronology of the Doctor Who TV universe, picking up on the tiniest details presented on-screen to form a theory of a cohesive, single continuity for the series’ entire run. It’s a bit like trying to piece together a vast, incomplete jigsaw and only managing to get some of the pieces to fit by filing down the edges. My task was to watch through the entire set of Jon Pertwee stories making notes on the continuity. Some of my notes were subsequently published in issues of TSV (here, here and here). I was particularly delighted to pinpoint the dating of The Time Monster thanks to an obscure one-line reference. This all took place a few years before The Discontinuity Guide (which took a similar approach to documenting series continuity) appeared; and indeed TSV was acknowledged as a source in that book.

However, having gone through this period of intense scrutiny of Doctor Who, I then found the habit rather hard to break. For a long time I found it difficult to simply watch an episode without mentally checking for references to times, dates and other minor details and how these might link into other stories.

Over the last couple of years watching new episodes of Doctor Who I’ve made a conscious effort to try to be less analytical, at least on a first viewing. I want to get back to a point where I can just enjoy the story without worrying about how The End of the World fits in with The Ark, or what it would take for The Christmas Invasion to exist in the same universe as The Ambassadors of Death.

I think with The Runaway Bride I’ve finally succeeded; last night when watching the story for the first time I managed to sit back, relax and just enjoy the story. I only had one brief slip-up when I caught myself wondering why the hole through to the centre of the Earth hadn’t caused its destruction or indeed yielded any Stahlman’s Gas!!


Jamas Enright said...

Yeah, I caught the Inferno reference too. And wondered how come the Doctor had never been back "that far" (in time) before and yet managed to encounter the hydrogen inrush of the big band... :)

Oh, but the trials and tribulations of being a Who geek. :)

But, for the most part, I was able to just let the episode unfold (without checking the time too!).

Paul Scoones said...

Just to be clear, I'm not at all knocking the fun that can be had from pulling the episodes apart and trying to make sense of these apparent contradictions (perhaps for instance the Doctor is only referring to how far back he's been in his current incarnation). I'm just advocating not doing that on a first viewing. I ruined The Christmas Invasion for myself last year, spending too long thinking about the contradictory Mars expedition and failing to just enjoy watching the episode!

Anonymous said...

Hey Paul, I know that feeling too and definitely try to watch an episode at least once without writing anything down or analysing it. That can all come later (and no doubt will)!

rob said...

I thought there was something wrong with me. I get that feeling too. I'm on edge completely the first time I watch a new episode. I was trying to explain it to my wife and I theorised that it was because it always feels fragile; as if after waiting for it to come back for so long there is a chance that if it isn't 'good' enough it may be lost again? Completely irrational at the moment though... although I wasn't a big fan of Evolution.